Comparison between electrochemical cell and electrolytic cell

The comparison between electrochemical cells and electrolytic cells highlights their distinct features and functions.

Electrochemical cell

Electrolytic cell

Converts chemical energy to electrical energy

Converts electrical energy to chemical energy

Flow of electrons determined by reactivity of chemical species

Flow of electrons determined by external power supply

Anode is negative, cathode is positive by convention

Anode is positive, cathode is negative by convention

May or may not require a salt bridge

May or may not require separate cells

Oxidation occurs at anode while reduction occurs at cathode

 

Previous article: Applications of electrolysis: Manufacture of chemicals
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

Applications of electrolysis: manufacture of chemicals

Electrolysis is widely used in the manufacture of chemicals, facilitating the production of essential substances like chlorine, sodium hydroxide, and hydrogen through the controlled decomposition of ionic compounds in solution.

1) The chloralkali process

The chloralkali process is an electrolytic process for the manufacture of H2, Cl2 and NaOH.

Concentrated NaCl (saturated brine) is pumped into the left compartment, and water is pumped into the right compartment. Chloride ions are oxidised at the inert titanium anode to form chlorine gas:

2Cl(aq) → Cl2 (g) + 2e

while water is reduced at the cathode to give hydrogen gas:

2H2O (l) + 2eH2 (g) + 2OH(aq)

A cation exchange membrane, which allows sodium ions but not hydroxide and chloride ions to flow from the left compartment to the right compartment, is used. Hence, NaOH is only formed in the right compartment with the overall reaction being:

2NaCl (aq) + 2H2O (l) → Cl2 (g) + H2 (g) + 2NaOH (aq)

Chlorine gas, which is formed in the left compartment, is piped out, where it reacts with water to give hydrochloric and hypochlorous acids. Finally, NaCl can be replaced with KCl or CaCl2 for the manufacture of KOH or Ca(OH)2, respectively.

 

2) The Castner-Kellner process

Another way to manufacture H2, Cl2 and NaOH is via the Castner-Kellner process. The main difference between this process and the chloralkali process is the use of a liquid mercury cathode, which lowers the activation energy for the reduction of Na+ to Na, allowing the otherwise thermodynamically infeasible reaction to proceed.

Upper compartment:

Concentrated NaCl is fed into the upper compartment where Cl is oxidised at the inert titanium anode to liberate Cl2.

2Cl(aq) → Cl2 (g) + 2e

At the same time, Na+ is reduced at the Hg cathode to Na, which then dissolves in the cathode to form an amalgam, Na/Hg, which in turn circulates to the lower compartment.

Na+ (aq) + eNa (s)

Na (s) + Hg (l) → Na/Hg (l)

Lower compartment:

Water that is fed into the lower compartment reacts with the Na/Hg amalgam to give NaOH, H2 and Hg, which is pumped back up to the upper compartment for reuse. Note that Na is oxidised to Na+ while hydrogen in water is reduced to H2.

2Na/Hg (l) + 2H2O (l) → 2NaOH (aq) + H2 (g) + 2Hg (l)

The overall redox reaction is:

2NaCl (aq) + 2H2O (l) → 2NaOH (aq) + H2 (g) + 2Cl2 (g)

 

next article: Comparison between electrochemical cell and electrolytic cell
Previous article: Applications of electrolysis: Anodising
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

 

Applications of electrolysis: anodising

Anodising is an electrolytic process to create an inert oxide layer on a metal, which is the anode and hence the name anodising. The diagram below shows the passivation of aluminium by the formation of a layer of aluminium oxide, which protects the aluminium from corrosion. Anodised aluminium is used in many products, e.g. aircraft parts, consumer electronic components, carabineers, etc.

At the anode:

2H2O (l) → O2 (g) + 4H+ (aq)+ 4e

The oxygen produced reacts with the anode to form the protective layer:

3O2 (g) + 4Al (s) → 2Al2O3 (s)

 

next article: Applications of electrolysis: Manufacture of chemicals
Previous article: Applications of electrolysis: Extraction of metals
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

Applications of electrolysis: refining of metals and electroplating

Electrolytic cell 4 in the earlier question is an example of the use of electrolysis to refine metals. Copper ore, which contains small amounts of other metals like Pt and Au, is the anode, while a piece of pure Cu is the cathode.

At the anode, Cu, which competes with H2O and SO42-, is preferentially oxidised to aqueous Cu2+ because it lies above H2O and SO42- in the electrochemical series and is more concentrated relative to the other two species (i.e., high number of Cu atoms in the electrode per unit volume as compared to the other two species in the electrolyte per unit volume).

Cu (s) Cu2+ (aq) + 2e

At the cathode, Cu2+, which competes with H2O, is preferentially reduced to Cu, as it is lower in the electrochemical series than H2O. Additionally, it is more concentrated relative to H2O.

Cu2+ (aq) + 2eCu (s)

The overall redox reaction results in the coating of a layer of pure copper on the surface of the pure copper cathode:

Cu (s) Cu (s)

If we replace the anode with a pure metal, e.g. Ni, and the electrolyte with an aqueous salt of the metal, e.g., NiSO4, a layer of Ni will coat the cathode (see diagram below). This is the principle of electroplating.

Examples of electroplating are:

Plating Metal, M

Plated object

Ni, Cr

Automotive parts, electrical appliances

Sn

Ornaments, jewelry

Ag, Au, Cu

Cutlery, ornaments, jewelry, electronic components

 

next article: Applications of electrolysis: Extraction of metals
Previous article: Analysing reactions in an electrolytic cell
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

 

Applications of electrolysis: extraction of metals

Electrolysis is a vital process in the extraction of metals from their ores, enabling the efficient separation of valuable elements through the application of electric current, which transforms metal ions into their solid form.

A theoretical way to obtain pure aluminium is to electrolyse molten Al2O3 (alumina). However, the melting point of Al2O3 is 2072 oC, making this method impractical. In the 1800s, French scientist Paul Héroult and American scientist Charles Hall developed a better method known as the Hall-Heroult process. In this process, Al2O3 is first dissolved in a solvent mixture of Na3AlF6 (cryolite) and AlF3 at about 1000 oC before being electrolysed to give pure aluminium.

Dissolution reaction:

Al2O3 (s) + 4[AlF6]3- (l) → 3[Al2OF6]2- (l) + 6F(l)

Solid alumina is dissolved in cryolite and AlF3 at about 1000 oC to give an oxyflouridealuminate complex.

 

At the anode:

2[Al2OF6]2- (l) 12F– (l)  4[AlF6]3- (l) + O2 (g) + 4e

O2 (g) + C (s) → CO2 (g)

The oxyflouridealuminate complex reacts with excess fluoride ions to give the hexafluoroaluminate complex and oxygen, which then oxidises the carbon anodes to yield carbon dioxide (note that at such high temperatures, the carbon anodes are no longer inert). The overall anode reaction is:

2[Al2OF6]2- (l) 12F– (l) + C (s)  4[AlF6]3- (l) + CO2 (g) + 4e

 

At the cathode:

[AlF6]3- (l) + 3e– Al (l) + 6F(l)

The hexafluoroaluminate complex is reduced to give pure molten aluminium.

 

The overall redox reaction is

2Al2O(s) + 3C (s) → 4Al (l) + 3CO2 (g)

As the carbon anodes are oxidised to carbon dioxide, they have to be replaced over time.

 

next article: Applications of electrolysis: anodising
Previous article: Applications of electrolysis: refining of metals and electroplating
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

 

Analysing reactions in an electrolytic cell

To analyse reactions in the PbBr2 electrolytic cell (see previous article), we follow these steps:

Step 1:  Determine the direction of flow of electrons

The flow of electrons in an electrolytic cell is determined by the way the battery (direct current source) is connected to the circuit. The battery is represented by two parallel lines with the longer line symbolising the positive terminal and the shorter one, the negative terminal.

For this example, the positive terminal of the battery is connected to the left electrode, while the negative terminal to the right electrode. Electrons flow from the negative terminal to the right electrode making it negatively charged. The negatively charged electrode attracts cations in the electrolyte towards its surface, where they undergo reduction. Hence, the electrode that is connected to the negative terminal of the battery is the cathode. Using the same logic, oxidation takes place at the left electrode, which is the anode.

Step 2:  Find out the reduction reaction at the cathode by

    • Identifying the reducible species (usually positive ions), which in this case is Pb2+. There is only one reducible species, as the electrolyte is molten PbBr2 and the electrodes are inert.
    • Distinguishing the species that is most readily reduced if there is more than one competing species by:
      • comparing the species on the electrochemical series: N.A.
      • comparing the concentrations of the species if their positions in electrochemical series are relatively near: N.A.
    • Writing the ionic half-reaction equation for the reduction:

Pb2+ (l) + 2ePb (l)

Step 3:  Find out the oxidation reaction at the anode by

    • Identifying the oxidisable species (usually negative ions): Br
    • Distinguishing the species that is most readily oxidised if there is more than one competing species by:
      • comparing the species on the electrochemical series: N.A.
      • comparing the concentrations of the species if their positions in electrochemical series are relatively near: N.A.
    • Writing the ionic half-reaction equation for the reduction:

2Br (l) Br2 (g) + 2e 

Combining the two half reaction equations, the overall redox reaction in the electrolytic cell is:

Pb2+ (l) + 2Br (l) Pb (l) + Br2 (g) 

Note that the electrolytic circuit is complete by the flow of electrons from the anode to the positive terminal of the battery via the wire and a net flux of negative ions towards the anode and positive ions towards the cathode in the electrolyte.

 

Question

What are the products at the anode and cathode for the following electrolytic cells?

Cell Electrode pair

Electrolyte

1

C/C

Concentrated NaCl

2

Pt/Pt

Acidified H2O

3

C/C

Dilute CuSO4

4

Cu/Cu

Dilute CuSO4

Answer

 

Cell

Species at anode

Products at anode

1

Cl, H2O

Cl2, since [Cl] >> [H2O]

2

H2O

O2

3

H2O, SO42

O2, since H2O is much higher in the electrochemical series than SO42-

4

Cu, H2O, SO42

Cu2+, since Cu is higher in the electrochemical series than H2O & SO42- and [Cu] >> [SO42-] & [H2O]

H2O is always assumed to be the species instead of OH in non-hydroxide aqueous solutions, as the concentration of OH from H2O is very small. Similarly, H2O is assumed to be the species instead of H+ in non-acidic aqueous solutions, as the concentration of H+ from H2O is very small.

Cell

Species at cathode

Products at cathode

1

Na+, H2O

H2, since H2O is much lower in the electrochemical series than Na+

2

H+, H2O

 Both species are reduced to H2, with H+ undergoing reduction first, as it is much lower in the electrochemical series than H2O. H2O will be reduced when [H+] falls appreciably.

3

Cu2+, H2O

Cu, since Cu2+ is much lower in the electrochemical series than H2O

4

Cu2+, H2O

Cu, since Cu2+ is lower in the electrochemical series than H2O

 

 

next article: Applications of electrolysis: Refining of metals and electroplating
Previous article: Electrolysis and the electrolytic cell
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

Electric double layer and electrode potential

An electric double layer consists of two layers of opposite charges that accumulate at the phase boundary between an electrode (a solid electrical conductor, e.g. a piece of zinc) and an electrolyte (a molten or an aqueous electrical conductor, e.g. aqueous zinc sulphate).

Zinc, according to the metal reactivity series, is a relatively reactive metal. When a zinc rod (an electrode) is placed in aqueous zinc sulphate, zinc atoms are easily oxidised to zinc ions, which enter the solution leaving free electrons on the surface of the electrode. At the same time, some zinc ions in the solution combine with free electrons in the electrode and are reduced to zinc atoms. Initially, more zinc atoms are oxidised to zinc ions than zinc ions are reduced to zinc atoms. As the concentration of zinc ions in the solution increases, an equilibrium is attained such that the rate of oxidation equals to the rate of reduction, and is represented by the following equation:

Zn^{2+}(aq)+2e^-\rightleftharpoons Zn(s)

The equilibrium position for zinc, when compared to less reactive metals, lies to the left of the above equation, resulting in an excess of electrons on the surface of the electrode, which attract zinc ions in the solution that are close to the surface to form two parallel array of charges called an electric double layer. Just like a ball at a certain height has the capacity to do work, opposite charges that are separated at a distance have the potential to do work too. We call such a potential, which arises due to the formation of the electric double layer, an electrode potential.

As the formation of the ions and electrons in the electric double layer depends on the reactivity of the metal, the electrode potential of a Zn/ZnSO4 system is greater than that of a less reactive metal, such as copper, which is characterised by an equilibrium position in aqueous copper sulphate that lies to the right of the following equation:

Cu^{2+}(aq)+2e^-\rightleftharpoons Cu(s)

If we connect the zinc and copper electrodes with a wire, the electrons are no longer contained in the respective electrodes. They flow from a region of higher electrode potential (higher energy) to a region of lower electrode potential (lower energy), i.e. from the zinc electrode to the copper electrode (see diagram below). This difference in electrode potentials is called the potential difference between the two systems. The further apart the two metals are in the metal reactivity series, the greater the potential difference. We call the linked electrodes and their respective salt solutions, an electrochemical cell, and the individual metal/metal salt solution system, a half-cell.

The overall electrochemical reaction is:

Zn(s)+Cu^{2+}(aq)\rightleftharpoons Zn^{2+}(aq)+Cu(s)

 

next article: Electrochemical cell

Previous article: Overview
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

Electrolysis and the electrolytic cell

Electrolysis is the use of electrical energy to carry out a redox reaction in an electrolytic cell, which is composed of a direct current source, e.g. a battery, connected to an electrochemical cell. The term ‘electrolysis’ was coined by Michael Faraday, who developed two laws of electrolysis in 1833.

The simplest electrolytic cell consists of two electrodes dipped in an electrolyte that may be a molten or aqueous compound. The electrodes are connected to each other via a direct current source, which supplies electrical energy for the redox reaction.

The choice of electrolyte is dependent on the objective of the electrolytic process. It could be a compound that assists the extraction of a useful metal, or simply one to maintain the flow of charges in the electrochemical cell. Similarly, the choice of electrodes is dictated by the aim of the process. Atoms of active electrodes may participate directly in the redox reaction in some processes, while inert electrodes like platinum or graphite are used when we want them to function purely as conductors. For example, the diagram above shows the electrolysis of PbBr2, with molten lead bromide being the electrolyte and graphite rods as the inert electrodes.

 

next article: Analysing reactions in an electrolytic cell
Previous article: The alkaline battery
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

The alkaline battery

Electrochemical cells are batteries. One of the most common forms of battery is the alkaline battery (alkaline because potassium hydroxide is the electrolyte).

At the anode:

Unlike electrochemical cells mentioned in an earlier article, the anode is not a piece of zinc but zinc particles suspended in a KOH electrolyte (ZnKOH paste). Zinc is oxidised to Zn2+ as follows:

Zn (s) + 2OH(aq) → ZnO (s) + 2H2O (l) + 2e

The free electrons are collected at the anode collector and flow out of the battery via the anode cap when the battery is connected to an external circuit to power an electronic device (see diagram below).

At the cathode:

Returning electrons enter the battery via the cathode cap and flow along the sides to the cathode collector and then to the cathode where they participate in the following reduction reaction:

2MnO2 (s) + H2O (l) + 2eMn2O3 (s) + 2OH– (aq)

Like the anode, the cathode is not a piece of manganese (IV) oxide but a paste of manganese (IV) oxide and carbon (carbon is added to improve conductivity). The porous cellulose separator prevents the electrode materials from mixing but allows hydroxide ions produced in the cathode to migrate across it to the anode to maintain electrical neutrality.

next article: Electrolysis and the electrolytic cell
Previous article: The fuel cell
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page

The fuel cell

A fuel cell converts chemical energy from the fuel (usually H2) to electrical energy, which is used to power engines. With reference to the diagram below, H2 is fed into the left compartment, where it is oxidised to H+ at the anode, which is porous and impregnated with a Pt catalyst. The protons then migrate across the electrolyte (H3PO4) contained in a polymer exchange membrane that only allows the passage of H+.

At the cathode, O2 in the air fed into the right compartment reacts with H+ and is reduced to form water. The cathode is again porous and impregnated with a Ni catalyst. The overall redox reaction is:

2H2 (g) + O2 (g) → 2H2O (l)

 

next article: The alkaline battery
Previous article: Other forms of electrochemical cell
Content page of basic electrochemistry
Content page of Basic chemistry
Main content page